About the Church of Our Saviour, Lutheran (COSL)

About Us

At COSL, we welcome you with open arms. Whether you’re a life-long Christian or skeptical but curious, ours is a church where you can join others to ask life’s big questions, grow closer to God and serve and love others just as Jesus did. 

Every Sunday, you can expect to hear beautiful music, be inspired by a thought-provoking sermon and catch up with old friends and make new ones at our lively coffee hour.

COSL is a church that loves children, who can be heard laughing, playing and learning together each week in our nursery and Sunday School.

You’ll have opportunities to help those in need, both locally and abroad, no matter how much time or money you have. And you’ll leave feeling more peaceful and energized as you head into your week.

What We Believe

Lutherans

The Lutheran tradition is a branch of Christianity started by Martin Luther, a Catholic monk in Germany in the 1500s. His key insight was that we don’t earn God’s love by being good. In fact, God loves as we are, without doing anything to earn that love. And that love is seen most clearly for us in the person of Jesus, whose radical welcome to all healed and transformed the lives he came into contact with. We believe the Spirit of that divine love meets us, and our lives are transformed today. 

Welcomed and transformed by that love, we become channels of that welcome and love in the world today.

We are members of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, a family of roughly 9000 congregations and 3.5 million members across the United States.

Who We Are

Our Leadership

Pastor Mary Shaima

Pastor Mary Shaima

Pastor Mary was born and raised in California where she was an active member of her home congregation as a liturgist and lead cantor until she felt the call to seminary to become a pastor herself.

Her life experience includes working as a paralegal for her late husband and running a bed and breakfast inn, to name a few. She has been a church musician since her youth, and has worked on Lutheran worship events at the local, regional, and national levels. She is also passionate about interfaith collaboration and the issues faced by First Nations peoples around the world.

She recently completed a five-year call in a small congregation in Washington State where she was known as an excellent liturgist and a strong administrator. She has a gift for pastoral care, education and building community within the congregation while also collaborating with local neighborhoods to seamlessly meet the needs of each.

Pastor Mary enjoys gardening, skiing, traveling, and making music.  She is excited about the opportunity to explore a new part of the country while being closer to her son who is stationed in North Carolina with the US Army.

Director of Music Ministries: Judith Feuss

Director of Music Ministries: Judith Feuss

Judith is a resident of Port Washington and is well known in the community, having served as Director of Music/Organist at the Reform Church of Manhasset and as organist at the Congregational Church of Manhasset. She taught general music and chorus at Northside Elementary School in Farmingdale and maintains an active studio of piano, voice, and woodwind students. Her career highlights include performing at the White House and the Vatican Pavilion at the World’s Fair.

Director of Youth Ministries: Jamie Stainkamp

Director of Youth Ministries: Jamie Stainkamp

Jamie is a lifelong member of Church of Our Saviour Lutheran, and her faith stands as a strong pillar of her identity. Jamie is passionate about encouraging young people to become active participants in both the church and their faith. At COSL, Jamie coordinates and leads both youth programs and early education programs, such as Sunday School. Jamie shepherds youngsters to develop and cultivate strong healthy relationships with their faith from a young age. She is a graduate from Concordia College-New York, in Bronxville, New York, holding a Bachelors and Masters Degree in Childhood Special Education. Jamie is currently a 4th grade teacher at Trinity Lutheran School in Hicksville.

Sexton: E. Antonio Centeno

Sexton: E. Antonio Centeno

Antonio, a native of El Salvador, courageously left his country to pursue a better life for himself and his family in the United States. Upon arriving in our nation, he held several jobs before ultimately accepting his current position with our congregation in November 1998. Since then we have been blessed to have Antonio cheerfully caring for the maintenance and repairs of our property and grounds. The congregation was proud to celebrate Antonio officially becoming a citizen of the United States in 2013.

Our History

For 85 years, the steeple of Church of Our Saviour Lutheran has stood as a welcoming beacon at the corner of Northern Boulevard and Copley Road. From its humble beginnings in a second floor room in Munsey Park Center used as a dog obedience school during the week and a beer hall on Saturday evenings, the church has blossomed into a vibrant, multi-generational community deeply rooted in Manhasset and extending its embrace far beyond.

Church of Our Saviour’s story is one of bold vision and steadfast dedication. In 1937, 31 determined individuals laid the church’s foundation, driven by a desire to create a space that emphasized the inclusive love of Christ. Just a few years later, in 1940, the congregation officially incorporated, choosing the name “Church of Our Saviour”. 

That resolve bore fruit in the purchase of prime Manhasset land in 1944 and the subsequent construction of the church, dedicated in 1950. Over the decades, the church expanded to include an educational wing, a preschool, a library, and a parsonage, each reflecting the congregation’s commitment to serving its members and the wider community. 

Church of Our Saviour has consistently looked outward, embodying its mission through outreach initiatives. From supporting sister congregations in Brooklyn and the Bronx to partnering in global mission work, its commitment to service has been a constant thread. Today, this dedication continues through supporting the New Life Center in Uniondale, participating in an annual meal packing event, and preparing Christmas gifts for Operation Christmas Child.

The church’s warmth and inclusivity are palpable, drawing members from 37 zip codes. The active and engaging nature of the congregation is evident in its many groups, from the harmonious voices of the choir and the dedicated service of the Fellowship Committee to the comforting creations of the Knit-Wits and the vital work of the Altar Guild and Bible Study groups. The vibrant children’s program nurtures faith from the youngest ages with childcare and Sunday School during Sunday worship along with engaging activities like the Easter Egg Hunt and Trunk or Treat, and meaningful participation in worship and service projects.

Congregation Council 2025

Jim Meredith, President

Kathy McNally, Vice President

Meghan Moin, Secretary

Bob Bishop

Janice Pupelis

Norma Steele

Sharon Rivilli

Janice Pupelis

Melissa Wall

Wayne Wink